IS IT AN OFFER TO SETTLE?

IS IT AN OFFER TO SETTLE?

COMMENT FOR THE DAY #53 MEDIATION Party A makes an offer in a mediation. Party B thinks the offer is “derisory” + an “insult”. Party B threatens to walk out of the mediation + inform the court that Party A did not engage in the mediation “in good faith” (i.e. in...
Can You Teach Discretion?

Can You Teach Discretion?

An interesting contradiction exists between the exercise of discretion on the one hand AND the need for Tribunal consistency on the other hand. Discretion means you are free to make up your own mind. There are constraints. You need to be fair + reasonable + objective...
Unconscious Bias

Unconscious Bias

Unconscious bias is a big issue. How do Mediators and Arbitrators deal with this problem? The difficulty is that the bias is not always recognised or detected and that is because the bias is nearly always unconscious. Our problem has been that we could only deal with...
Standards Of Behaviour

Standards Of Behaviour

Yesterday morning I wrote about dispute resolvers need for integrity and character. Today I focus on standards of behaviour – an essential part of a dispute resolver’s make up. Ego is the danger here. We all need some ego because ego and self-confidence go...
FAMILY SEPARATION  – TWO CHILDREN OR THREE?

FAMILY SEPARATION – TWO CHILDREN OR THREE?

A marriage has broken up. There are three children aged – 7, 4 and four months. There are assets but not large. The husband is a self-employed accountant with average means. The wife took in part-time work until the birth of the baby. You have accepted the appointment...