Thought For The Day

LENGTHY ORAL SUBMISSIONS – EPISODE 5

ARBITRATION #132 FINAL EPISODE (5) Sometimes arbitrators want comprehensive opening statements – and sometimes they don’t. It depends on the case, the bundles, the legal authorities, the witnesses. Where it is unnecessary, say so. But where it is necessary, consider...

LENGTHY ORAL SUBMISSIONS – EPISODE 4

ARBITRATION #131 The appellant’s advocate was indignant. You have touched a chord. His ego has taken a knock. But that is not your concern. You have one Master – Fairness. Avoiding unnecessary costs + avoiding delays is also being fair. The arguments of both sides...

LENGTHY ORAL SUBMISSIONS – EPISODE 3

ARBITRATION #130 Picking up from yesterday, you are back in the Hearing Room with parties, transcribers, + observers. “We have an issue that we want to raise with the parties. We have received, in good time, pre-hearing submissions + documents. These have been read +...

LENGTHY ORAL SUBMISSIONS – EPISODE 2

ARBITRATION  #128 You, the Chair, are being tested. Does the Tribunal need to listen to claimants' 43-page opening statement at the start of Day 1? You caucus with the two wingers. What is their view? They have to go first so that if there is a difference of opinion...

AN ANXIOUS NEW ARBITRATOR – EPISODE 2

The parties to the arbitration are a firm of international grain traders – who appointed Arbitrator A – and a firm of Far East processors with plants in Malaysia– who appointed Arbitrator B.

Trending Now

PRODUCING UNHELPFUL DOCUMENTS

PRODUCING UNHELPFUL DOCUMENTS

You are sole arbitrator. You have moved on to considering damages. You think that both parties might be holding back market evidence they have obtained which does not support their submissions. Do you have the authority to direct both parties to disclose all the...

SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS

SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS

You remember the problem? Party A authorises you to offer payment of £100,000 to settle a dispute. You then go to Party B but before you can convey the offer Party B informs you that they will accept £80,000. Ouch! You could go back to A and tell them that they can...

ARBITRATION – ADVERSARIAL OR INQUISITORIAL?

ARBITRATION – ADVERSARIAL OR INQUISITORIAL?

s 34 Arbitration Act 1996 "It shall be for the tribunal to decide all procedural and evidential matters, subject to the right of the parties to agree any matter... (2) Procedural and evidential matters include — --- (g) whether and to what extent the tribunal should...

Settlement Offers Can Create Problems

Settlement Offers Can Create Problems

You are doing a commercial mediation. Things are going well. There is movement and open minds. In a private meeting, Party A authorises you to inform Party B that Party A will accept an immediate one-off payment of £80,000 from Party B in settlement of the dispute....

LIST THE ISSUES

LIST THE ISSUES

As a Chair of five arbitrators on an Appeal Board, I always focused on listing the issues. It brings focus + clarity to your work. No list + issues can slip through the net. This is not just a fail safe tactic - it serves two specific purposes;- First, - if you get it...

MEDIATION CONUNDRUM

MEDIATION CONUNDRUM

An employee is fired. The grounds are not strong. He agrees to mediation. Actually you have a subjective sympathy for him but you know that this cannot blur your judgement. You know you have to remain neutral but you do feel he has been manipulated. The firm is...

Graham Perry

Author 

Mr Graham Perry M.A. Cantab FCIArb

Experienced Arbitration Lawyer | China & Chinese Business Affairs | Public Speaker/Lecturer